Characterizing the Retention of UPW Filters Using Enhanced SEMI C79 Testing
Gary Van Schooneveld, Mark Litchy, Don Grant – CT Associates, Inc.
Uwe Beuscher, Kevin Cresswell – WL Gore and Associates
Particles in ultrapure water (UPW), used during the manufacture of microcircuits on semiconductor
wafers, can deposit onto the wafer surface thereby causing decreased yield and reliability of the
microcircuits. As microcircuit future sizes continue to decrease, understanding the ability of a filter to
capture and retain these particles becomes increasingly important and challenging.
In 2013, SEMI C79-0113, “Guide to Evaluate the Efficacy of Sub-15 nm Filters used in Ultrapure Water
(UPW) Distribution System” was published. This document provides a SEMI recommended method
for evaluating the efficacy of filter elements used to remove particles in UPW fluid streams. Since the
release of this guide, the method has been enhanced to allow quantification of particle retention over
a broad size range. This was accomplished by adding larger silica particles to the Ludox® SM30 silica
specified by SEMI C79 resulting in a poly-dispersed silica challenge. A particle size distribution (PSD)
slope of -2 (log-log) was selected so the challenge would more closely mimic a PSD typically found
in UPW, yet still have sufficient large particles to measure a log retention value of 2 or 99% retention.
This silica challenge has been designated as an “area-weighted challenge”.
The use of this enhanced method has resulted in some interesting observations including indication
of a most penetrating particle size similar to what is observed in gas filtration. The presence of a most
penetrating particle size would indicate that retention mechanisms other than sieving are active,
particularly for particles smaller than 30 nm.
This paper will review the enhancements made to the test method, review the retention data from a
number of filter types and manufacturers, and discuss the implications for filters used in UPW.
CTA publication #131: Ultrapure Micro Journal Vol 1 No 1 2018